Showing posts with label about. Show all posts
Showing posts with label about. Show all posts

The Last Four Years

I haven’t shared an update here on what I have been up to since the end of the Obama Administration, so now’s a good time to write some of this down.

Like many, I was extremely worried by Donald Trump’s election to the Presidency. Doing all I could to get to a different result in 2020 drove much of my work since 2017. I also tried to extend my non-profit work and grow my fundraising ability because I came to the sad realization that my fundraising ability is worth at least as much, if not more, than my strategic advice to the non-profits I care about (and I am not very good at fundraising).

All of the projects below were overlapping, and most were not full-time. They combined to be a ridiculous amount of work sometimes, and nearly no work at other times. The list below is in somewhat chronological order.

  • Thanks to Megan Smith and Tom Perez, I got to help bring in Raffi Krikorian to be the first Chief Technology Officer of the Democratic National Committee (DNC). Tom understood the value of tech and how badly Democrats were being beaten in this regard. He helped re-up tech within the DNC and the team has done amazing stuff under Raffi and Lindsey Schuh Cortes, and now Nellwyn Thomas and Kat Atwater.

  • Thanks to Mike Yang, Haley van Dÿck and Mikey Dickerson, I helped found Alloy.us and was its General Counsel for the first year. Alloy’s mission was to help improve data and technology for the progressive ecosystem. We were originally focused on legal data sharing among progressive organizations and campaigns, but once the Democratic Data Exchange (DDx) got up and running, and based on feedback from potential users, we shifted to improving basic data availability and update frequency, as well as voter registration. The wonderful Kendall Burman took over as General Counsel on January 1st, 2020. Alloy is now in talks with CiviTech to have them carry on our mission. I’m thankful for the incredible people we were able to hire, many of whom I had not met before, and for the fact that Alloy seems to have had a positive impact on the election and Georgia runoffs through its set of partners.

  • While working on the tech and data side for Dems and progressives, I also got drawn into, and did some funding of, and fundraising for, a wide set of organizations and candidates. One of the most amazing things to come out of 2016 was the incredible set of new organizations and candidates. The narrow 2016 loss to the person who would become one of the worst presidents in American history was also a catalyst for a bunch of more established organizations to do great work. I am really grateful to the many, many people who shared their wisdom and time as I was getting up to speed (I still am). I am also grateful to the folks who did the work of registering a record breaking number of new voters, helped to elect good candidates, including President Biden, and then protected those victories against the efforts to undo them. Before 2016 I had no idea of the richness and variety of people and organizations that are part of the big tent of the progressive community and Democratic party. It looks chaotic at times, but I was constantly blown away by the talented, committed people who work in politics. Many do so without much compensation or limelight, and nearly everyone I met shared a basic common purpose that was tied to getting real benefits for people.

  • Thanks to Eric Goldman, Adelin Cai, Clara Tsao, and Denelle Dixon-Thayer, I got to help found the Trust & Safety Professional Association (TSPA) and the Trust & Safety Foundation Project (TSF). I’ve wanted to do something like this for fifteen years but it took others to push for their formation.  I had the good fortune of getting to know some great Cognizant folks, including Kristen Titus and Davis Abraham, and many others while fundraising for TSPA and TSF. And then I got to talk to many old friends and make some new ones as we considered who would be the perfect first Executive Director. I couldn’t be happier that Charlotte Willner took the job. Being so immersed in a community I have been around for a long time was deeply satisfying. And the collective “FINALLY!!!” we heard on launching underscored to me that community building is important and should never be put off.

  • I’ve also spent a good amount of time working as a Board Member at Creative Commons and Data & Society. They are two great organizations from which I have learnt a lot. I am the Board lead for fundraising at both places, and so have been asking many of my friends for money to support their wonderful missions. Being a Board Member is also something I am still learning, and I have been thankful to get to watch others who are better at it than I, and to have such an intimate view of these two very different organizations during these exceptional times. I still also exist as a fanboy for the work that Creative Commons and Data & Society each do, so it is great to feel like I am helping them achieve their goals.

  • More recently, thanks to Yohannes Abraham, DJ Patil, David Recordon, Ginny Hunt, Mina Hsiang, Eric Hysen, Clarence Wardell and many others, I was lucky to get to work on the Biden Transition (and with my old friend and mentor Nicole Wong). That was a huge privilege and again underscored that working with a great team, on hard problems, with one clear purpose is a wonderful experience. I am so pleased for the folks who are going into government (and will try to write more about some of them soon). If you want to learn more about transitions, Transition Lab is a fabulous podcast and episode 46 (!!) is with  Yohannes.

I would not have thought in 2016 that I would have spent a large portion of the next four years in politics and political tech. Nor would I have thought I would have helped found three non-profits. So while I continue to be on the Board at Alloy, Creative Commons, Data & Society, TSPA and TSF, I really don’t know what the next of these updates will look like. After President Biden’s heartwarming inauguration, I am very hopeful for us all.

Finally, if you got this far and are wondering what to donate to in the new year with the hellishness of COVID still in full swing, please consider using this tool to find your local food bank and donate. I have a longer and slightly older list of COVID charities here, but know that many are having a very hard time getting basics like food and shelter, so please be generous.

First Time in Government

“The President of the United States is going to call you in three hours to offer you the job, so I need to know in two whether you will say yes because we do not surprise the President.” That’s what Todd Park, U.S. Chief Technology Officer (CTO), said to me in August of 2014 as our family was about to head back to San Francisco for the new school year.
Todd Park, Assistant to the President and Chief Technology Officer
shows President Obama information on a tablet April 15, 2013.
Official White House Photo by Pete Souz
In those two hours, I tried to figure out if I could really make a significant positive impact in the job the President would offer me as Deputy U.S. CTO. And, if so, whether that was worth moving our family.  The ability to make a positive impact is generally my north star when trying to make job decisions, but time and again, when I am looking back on whether taking a job was the right decision, the quality of the team I got to work with is always most important. Now that I’ve had some time to reflect on my time in government, and the entire Obama team has moved on from team CTO, I know that this time was no different. While I am extremely grateful for the impact of the work I was privileged to do, I am most happy about my time in government because of the the people I got to do it with.

The Eisenhower Executive Office Building, home of the
U.S. CTO, pictured c 1907, then the State, War & Navy Building
Gall, George, Washington: The Capital of the Nation (1907).
Digitized by The Internet Archive from the Library of Congress

The impact of government work was amazing. Our purpose was clear: help make life better for and with the American people. Under President Obama, Team CTO had significant impact working together along with many others in our home at the Office of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP), elsewhere in the White House, and across the Federal Government. We supported the work done by previous CTO teams to bring tech capacity to government in the form of the Presidential Innovation Fellows, 18F, U.S. Digital Service, and revamped Office of Digital Strategy. We brought more data science and data scientists into government through the creation of the U.S. Chief Data Scientist team and role, and creating a data science cabinet. We expanded data collaborations for solutions in justice, jobs, housing, education, and more, while continuing to get more government data out to the public. The Open Government Partnership (OGP) continued to thrive and grow and we shepherded the U.S. Open Government National Action Plans while teaming up with the National Security Council and State Department to help lead the U.S. OGP. With support from the Chief of Staff, we created a new tool for tech policy making called the Tech Policy Task Force -- which added “TQ” to many policy tables, formulated a federal source code policy, moved the government forward on artificial intelligence and uncrewed aerial vehicles, accelerated open educational resources, highlighted the opportunities and challenges of big data and algorithmic decision making, and worked with the Departments of Education, Transportation, Commerce, State, Homeland Security, Justice, and others to help regulations get out of the way of innovation while protecting people’s rights and lives. We pushed for greater recognition of all American talent, including women and underrepresented minorities in STEM; catalyzing for improvements in the portrayal of STEM people in media; expanding inclusive opportunity in computer science education; ensuring outreach for jobs in innovative industries in hiring programs, such as TechHire; increasing Internet connectivity in the U.S. and around the world; championing innovative local community solutions; pushing through more diversity and inclusion in the Federal government workforce; and expanding best practices in organizations and companies in diversity, equity, and inclusion, including an implementation action grid, the Tech Inclusion Pledge, and expanded inclusive venture funding.  And, lots more. Even reading the list brings a tired smile to my face.


President Obama writes his first line of code and celebrates
with the middle school student who helped teach him, Dec. 8 2014.
Official White House Photo by Pete Souza
So, while there was no shortage of impact, I still would say that it was the people that were the most important reason why I was so glad that I had the opportunity to work government. The diversity of people in the White House and at agencies was a huge difference from Silicon Valley. That diversity was expressed in terms of the traditional lines of socio-economic, ethnicity, race, color, religion, age, disability status, gender identity, sexual orientation, and far more balanced gender representation, but also in terms of point of view, educational, geographic origin, and career background. Sometimes, I was among others like me but more frequently I was unusual along a number of dimensions such as my lack of long federal service, my lack of military service, my tech background, etc. I came away extremely impressed with the level of experience, intellect, and passion that the Obama White House was able to attract. There were people who you later discovered were Rhodes Scholars, or Supreme Court clerks, or had beaten a Scrabble world champion over the weekend. I had expected both the diversity and excellence, but it is one thing to expect something and quite another to live it for two-plus years.


President Obama talks with U.S. CTO Megan Smith, and
OSTP Director Dr. John Holdren, Oct. 8, 2014.
Official White House Photo by Pete Souza
Team CTO under U.S. CTO Megan Smith was also outstanding. I had the privilege of working with a number of people that I have admired and wanted to work for for years. I also got to meet and work with a bunch of folks that I might never have otherwise met. Over my time there, the U.S. CTO team while I was there included at different times: Puneet Ahira, Seth Andrew, Rob Bacchus, Jake Brewer, Marvin Carr, Jimmy Catania, Colleen Chien, Evan Cooke, R. David Edelman, Ed Felten, Anjali Fernandes, Brian Forde, Brianna Fugate, Dipayan Ghosh, Vivian Graubard, Renee Gregory, Dan Hammer, Natalie Evans Harris, Read Holman, Kristen Honey, Mina Hsiang, Kelly Jin, Terah Lyons, Matthew McAllister, Dawn Mielke, Lynn Overmann, Ryan Panchadsaram, DJ Patil, Tom Power, Laura Weidman Powers, Jason Schultz, Nick Sinai, Lauren Smith, Ashkan Soltani, Suhas Subramanyam, Emily Tavoulareas, Maya Uppaluru, Aden Van Noppen, Nancy Weiss, Claudia Williams, Charles Worthington, Cori Zarek, and, of course, the wonderful Megan Smith herself.




Some of the wonderful folks that made up team CTO,
Jan. 14, 2017.

That combination of a top-notch team amid a diverse broader group of excellent folks from top to bottom at OSTP, the broader White House and across the Government, made going into work both a joy and a challenging learning experience every day. I felt like I grew a ton, learned a lot about how the U.S. government functions, and picked up some really interesting management and leadership lessons from the people I got to work with. I came home mentally worn out but almost always smiling. I also made a bunch of new friends.

President Obama talks with Girl Scout White House Science
Fair participants who had designed a Lego page turner to help
people read books who may not otherwise be able, Mar. 23 2015.
Official White House Photo by Pete Souza

Now that I have been out of work for a few months, I am thankful for the opportunity to make a positive impact but I am certain that I made the right choice that August because of the amazing people I got to work with. I am still fired up that I had the privilege to serve with each and every one of them, and ready to go and work with them again!

President Obama, listens during a technology 
strategy discussion, Oct. 8, 2014.

Bio

Photo by Doc Searls, CC BY-SA

Alexander Macgillivray, also known as "amac," is curious about many things including ethics, law, policy, government, decision making, the Internet, algorithms, social justice, access to information, coding, and the intersection of all of those.


He worked on the Biden transition team and administration as Deputy Assistant to the President and Principal Deputy United States Chief Technology Officer and held a similar position in the Obama Administration. He was part of the founding team at the Trust & Safety Professional Association and Alloy.us. He was also a proud board member at Data & Society and Creative Commons, and an advisor to the Mozilla Tech Policy Fellows. 

He was Twitter's General Counsel, and head of Corporate Development, Public Policy, Communications, and Trust & Safety. Before that he was Deputy General Counsel at Google and created the Product Counsel team. He has served on the board of the Campaign for the Female Education (CAMFED) USA, was one of the early Berkman Klein Center folks, was certified as a First Grade Teacher by the State of New Jersey, and studied Reasoning & Decision Making as an undergraduate.

For more about what he is proudest of during his last few jobs see:
For a more resume-like experience, check out his LinkedIn.

Photo by Yash Mori, White House Photographer


New Job


And, in honor of the new gig, here's a very old public domain picture of the White House from Theodore Roosevelt's Programme of Exercises and Illustrated Inaugural History, 1905. 


  

Some News and Thanks

I will soon pass the Twitter General Counsel torch to Vijaya Gadde (@vijaya). Vijaya has been managing Twitter’s corporate and international legal work, and I’ve gotten to know her well over the last fourteen years. I couldn’t be happier with her appointment as General Counsel of Twitter.


As we transition, I will dial back my day to day involvement with Twitter. I’ll continue to support the company and its great people by staying on as an advisor for the legal, trust & safety, corporate development and public policy teams. I continue to care deeply about Twitter, the folks who work at Twitter and our tremendous users, so I’ll remain close to all three.


It has been a joy to work at Twitter. I have been fortunate to support the multiple award winning trust, public policy, corporate development, legal and, at various times during my tenure, communications and trust engineering teams. These are phenomenal teams made up of great people. I also continue to be awestruck by the many, varied, incredible ways people use Twitter.


I am proud to have worked with colleagues who defend and respect the user’s voice; who push freedom of expression and transparency; and who innovate and lead. Together we’ve brought some incredible products and talent into Twitter. We’ve supported teams creating new businesses and pushing to reach every person on the planet. Twitter continues to employ some of the funniest, most generous, smart, passionate and humble people I’ve ever met. I was lucky to get to work with them, and you can too.


To my teams, all the folks who work at Twitter and Twitter users: Thank you. I can’t wait to see what you do together next.


As for me, it has been my privilege to work and fight on behalf of great companies and their users over the last decade. A privilege and a lot of work. So, I’m looking forward to engaging my various internet passions from new and different perspectives, seeing friends and family without distraction, and just goofing off a bit. We should all do more of that.


More to come here and at @amac.

Public Domain Images courtesy of Google Books, sourcing here and here.

Twitter

Today was my first day at Twitter. Good vibe about the place. Shouldn't change this blog much though it may allow me to blog a bit more about copyright since I won't be dealing with those issues at work.

On Leaving Google

Working in Google Legal has been a dream job. The people at Google are phenomenal. In every part and at every level of the company there are great people with multiple useful talents in addition to those that got them the job. For a lawyer, the issues we dealt with every day were fascinating, the real-world impact of our work was humbling, and the ethical compass of the place remained true

Among many other things, I am proud to have been part of the legal department that helped:

Increase transparency for removals: Google remains the only search engine that sends legal notices to ChillingEffects.org to document search results suppressed for legal reasons. UPDATE: I'm pleased to report that as of sometime in the last few months, Yahoo! is sending at least some (maybe all) of their notices to ChillingEffects. This is GREAT news and I apologize to Yahoo! for not noticing this earlier.

Stand up to the Department of Justice: Google was the only search engine provider that stood up to the Department of Justice’s overbroad request for search query information.

Launch Google Book Search: Google is making books easier to find by using fair use for a great purpose and is working to expand access to books through the Book Search settlement.

Stand up for users: In my experience, Google does “focus on the user.” Google Legal is no exception in its decisions about everything from global product functionality to individual removals. As a result, we’ve been threatened or sued many times for user-focused functionality and what our users have said through our services.

There are many other examples, and many more that are confidential or privileged, but these give you a flavour of the types of things the Google legal department gets to do. I still can’t recommend it highly enough (really, go check out the jobs page).

Thank you Googlers, it was an honour.

I Use Cookies

Bricoleur.org uses Google Analytics to understand how users get to and use the site. Through Google, Analytics collects the information sent by your browser as part of a web page request, including cookies and your IP address. This information is used to generate reports, such as a guess of how many different visitors come to bricoleur.org. It does not identify you personally.
Cookies may be turned off and/or deleted through your browser. Mozilla provides details on how to turn off cookies for Firefox. I couldn't find an equivalent page on Microsoft's site, though I am sure it exists.
Google also receives this information and their use of it is governed by their Privacy Policy.

Updating Feed

I've updated my feed serving to Feedburner.

I'm Back

Am not sure how much I'll end up posting, but I went through the extremely hard work of porting my blog over to Blogger and setting it back up, so I'm back. I guess I should also say that I am still at Google working the legal side of the many great products that our engineers and other talented folk come up with. My team is hiring if you are interested.

Month Off

So, I've take almost a month off web logging. Have been really busy in the interim and away from computers. Got a new job, quit my old one. Took a trip to the New Orleans Jazz and Heritage Festival and to visit some old friends at the Berkman Center. Now I am back to work and back to web logging though I will be linking less, (hopefully) commenting more, linking to a few things others' haven't and also posting more code. At least that's the plan.

Humble Blogging

Donna Wentworth, speaking at last night's Weblogs, Information & Society (very eloquently IMHO, contrary to her self-criticism>), said that one of the things she loves about blogging is that it allows her to apprentice at the hands of many greats. I couldn't agree more. Linking and commenting is apprenticeship. You read, learn and, most importantly, integrate the thoughts of others with your own to figure out whether you understand them. Feedback is also important and that is where trackbacks and Technorati's link cosmos come in handy. There are few enough of us bloggers that when we link to the masters, they check out our writing and let us know when we are wrong.


Knowing too that, as Dan Gilmor said at the same conference, our readers always know more than us, a master on a point or of the moment will be an apprentice on the next. Humble blogging is best.

Description of Legal Bricolage

A friend of mine who has been a courts reporter for a daily newspaper and is now freelancing about, among other things, digital rights issues, sent me the following:


I think [litigating internet issues is] along the
lines of playing cowboy, but instead of cattle, you're roping the abyss. When
I was writing about the courts, so much of it dealt with established criminal
statutes that it was hard to find something unique -- it usually involved a
tiny point of federal sentencing guidelines. Here, it's completely under
construction -- the laws are still being written and the new ones are still
being tested.

Good luck building the barn...

Of course, that made my day, but I am not sure we are so unique either in the legal profession or in the world. I wrote back:



You made my day. Thanks, never been called a cowboy before. But, this is true of every type of law -- I think. If you look closely enough, there are always issues that have never been heard, or facts that laws have never been applied to, or the need to come up with a creative application of some old legal doctrine or new statute. As with journalism, whatever story you are currently working on has never been told the way you are about to tell it (and you get to be learning along the way). Probably why I love my job and why freelancing is such a kick.

And, why I think bricolage is something that we all do and that we all could do more of.

More on "Les Bricoleurs"

Got a compliment today from the inimitable Denise Howell of Bag and Baggage. This made my day because I respect Denise tons and because she included the following new tidbit regarding "Les Bricoleurs:"



In essence, bricolage is what tinkers do -- collecting odd bits of stuff they think may be potentially useful, then using whatever bits seem to work in the context of some later repair job. Simple. And yet profound. Because the bits the bricoleur ends up using were not designed for the use they end up being put to. Figuring out which bits to collect and how to apply them to some task at hand requires a completely different kind of thinking than the procedural algorithmic thought processes business has become so dependent upon. While the Internet may have convinced some businesses to think "out of the box," most are still not even sure what box they’re in, much less which way to turn for emergency egress. If some unprincipled individual were to yell "fire!" right about now, the entire edifice of global commerce might suddenly collapse.

From Introduction to Gonzo Marketing, by Christopher Locke (also of Cluetrain fame).

What Law?

My principal legal interests are all forms of intellectual property law and internet issues (such as access, speech, etc.). These issues are the reason that I went to law school and, so far, I haven't been able to shake my interest in them.


I work as an attorney at Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati in Palo Alto, California (though recently I have been working in the San Francisco office). There I do intellectual property litigation and internet counseling.


My clients at WSGR have included Napster, Google, Borland, StreamCast Networks (also known as MusicCity), Canal+, Inktomi, the Project to Promote Competition and many lesser known companies.


Two recent public pleadings in which I had a hand are:



WSGR's clients have great, interesting, highly technical, unique and fun legal issues to confront. They are what make me enjoy my work.


I also provide counselling to Creative Commons, the Online Policy Group and the Media Awareness Project. I am a sometime contributor to Chilling Effects and an editor at GrepLaw.

What to Code?

I program mostly on the side, for fun. However, from time to time coding projects are directly useful to doing my job.


For the moment, my principal coding projects (links to come) are:



  1. GrepMoodMusic: The idea here is to be able to have playlists generated on the fly based on a listener's mood and listening history.
  2. NewsGet: An RSS feed reader on steriods. It remembers what you read and can accept any feed defined by perl regexes and a uri.
  3. Fun with the patent databases:The USPTO database contains lots of juicy information that ought to be extracted.

I'd also like to learn python and lisp. I still maintain Public.law and HLSNet. And, I am a tester for the h2o Project and the Creative Commons license chooser.

Why Bricoleur?

The simplest answer is because that is how I would describe myself, and there don't seem to be any better words in english.


According to pages found through google's glossary (where else would one turn?), "bricoleur" is:


A French word with no exact English equivalent used as a term by Seymour Papert to describe the style of approach exemplified by a tinkerer or a jack of all trades. Bricoleurs are comfortable in unfamiliar realms of learning and experience because they learn best by using indirect connections to known information, even if the details of the skills are not exactly related. They try things out until they figure out how to do something.

Courtesy of the Tech Learning Link Glossary. Also check out the google glossary entry for bricolage


I first heard of this characterization of what I think is my approach to learning from Sherry Turkle's great book The Second Self: Computers and the Human Spirit .


In our post-DMCA world the positive benefits of being able learn through tinkering is a hot topic. Ed Felton's excellent web log called "Freedom to Tinker" and the Yale web log called "LawMeme: Legal Bricolage for a Technological Age" are but two examples.